• Reviews
    • 5+++++++ Stars
    • 5 stars
    • 4-5 stars
      • 4 stars
      • 4.25 Stars
      • 4.5 stars
      • 4.75 Stars
    • 3-4 stars
    • audiobook
      • Audiobooks Under 3 stars
      • Audiobook 3 stars
      • Audiobook 3.5 stars
      • Audiobook 3.75 Stars
      • Audiobook 4 stars
      • Audiobook 4.25 Stars
      • Audiobook 4.5 Stars
      • Audiobook 4.75 Stars
      • Audiobook 5 stars
      • Audiobook 5+++ Stars
  • Series Orders
    • The Complete Guide To Kristen Ashley
    • Tara Sivec Reading Guide
  • About
    • Advertising
    • Contact ~ Review Requests
    • Terms and Conditions. Privacy Policy.
    • Archive
  • Wicked Book Weekend

Ana's Attic Book Blog

Romance Book and Audiobook Reviews and Deals

  • Ana's Attic Book Blog
  • Home
  • Reviews
    • 5+++++++ Stars
    • 5 stars
    • 4-5 stars
      • 4 stars
      • 4.25 Stars
      • 4.5 stars
      • 4.75 Stars
    • 3-4 stars
    • Audiobooks
      • Audiobook 5+++ Stars
      • Audiobook 5 stars
      • Audiobook 4.75 Stars
      • Audiobook 4.5 Stars
      • Audiobook 4.25 Stars
      • Audiobook 4 stars
      • Audiobook 3.75 Stars
      • Audiobook 3.5 stars
      • Audiobook 3 stars
      • Audiobooks Under 3 stars
  • New-Sale-Free-Preorder
    • Monthly Release Recaps
  • Favorite Lists
    • Formula One Romance Novels
    • Jewish Contemporary Romance Novels
    • 2024 Top Picks
    • 2023 Top Picks
    • 2022 Top Picks
    • 2021 Top Picks
    • 2020 Top Picks
    • 2019 Top Picks
    • 2018 Top Picks
    • 2017 Top Picks
    • 2016 Top Picks
    • 2015 Top Picks
    • 2014 Top Picks
    • 2013 Top Picks
    • 2012 Top Picks
    • Christmas Romance Novels 2024
    • Hannukah Romance Novels 2024
    • Christmas Novels 2023
    • Hanukkah Romance Novels 2023
    • Top Picks: Books about Books
    • Top Picks and Favorite Lists
    • Recaps and Best Sellers
  • Upcoming Book Releases
F1 Romance Novels

Book Review – The Guy on the Left by Kate Stewart

04/23/2020

The Guy on the Left (The Underdogs Book 2) by Kate Stewart

Contemporary Romance. Book 2 in a related Series. 

I loved The Guy on the Right by Kate Stewart so much that I immediately jumped into The Guy on the Left. Though I haven’t really been reading, I needed Troy’s story and wasn’t willing to wait for the audiobook. The Guy on the Left can easily stand alone because the events run concurrently with The Guy on the Right, but to fully appreciate all that is behind Troy, I think these books should be read in order.

“In your eyes, I’ll always be the teenager who lied and got you pregnant. Not the man you rely on.”

Troy and Clarissa met years ago when he was still in high school. He pretended to be older and hooked up with Clarissa, a teacher. That union resulted in the most adorable kid, Dante, but Clarissa refuses to have anything to do with Troy. Still, he has been there, watching over them all along. Now that Troy is a senior in college and it looks like he will be drafted by the NFL, he is not hanging back anymore.

“You keep punishing me for something you won’t let me apologize for, for something you won’t ever let me make up to you.” He rakes his teeth across his bottom lip. “But I want to, Clarissa. Oh, how I want to.”

While Troy came off like a fun, popular, womanizing man-whore in the first book, we really got to know him in The Guy on the Left, and let me tell you, Clarissa and Dante are so lucky to have him. He is so devoted to Dante and it just broke my heart that Dante didn’t know.

Speaking of Dante, that little boy kind of stole the show. I want to buy the merch from this pint-sized YouTuber! And Troy’s relationship with Dante—I know I already said it but…Le sigh…. But it’s his relationship with Clarissa that really needs work, and she wants nothing to do with him. Especially because every time she lets her guard down, he screws up. OMG, the angst! I don’t know how Clarissa held out.

Do you think about that night? His voice is low, gravelly, and sexy as hell.
“D-d-do you?” my voice is just as affected. “Do you even remember it?”
“It was the hottest fucking night of my life. Of course, I remember it. …The way you kissed me back. Fuck, the way you kissed me back. You didn’t hold back with me. I remember that the most.”

The Guy on the Left was a longer and deeper read than the first. While there was still humor, this time it was more in the form of comic relief by Dante and Parker, Clarissa’s best friend. Otherwise it was raw, it was real, it was layered, it was slow burning, and it was sexy as hell.

“I’ve memorized you, Clarissa, the shape of your lips, the lilt of your voice, your every smile, every mood, your everything. I used to think it was because I’ve grown so used to watching because of Dante,” he wipes another tear from my cheek, “but it’s not just our son, baby, it’s you. He wasn’t the only one I was falling for.”

While at times I got frustrated with Clarissa, at other times I didn’t blame her. Troy was a manwhore at first but he proved himself over and over and I really did get annoyed that Dante didn’t know. But Troy and Clarissa were messy. And real. And The Guy on the Left was another amazing Kate Stewart ride.

Likes:

  • Dante. I love that kid, and I love his relationship with Troy.
  • Seeing Theo and Lainey and how the story ran concurrently with The Guy on the Right.
  • There were just so many layers to this story that really built throughout.
  • Troy proved himself over and over and was just the perfect guy.
  • Just the right amount of emotion to angst to comedy.
  • Parker. I loved her so much!

Dislikes:

  • Clarissa held out too long IMO, and it made me have trouble really liking her, which, to me is the most important factor in me loving a book.
  • I didn’t like Troy’s sluttiness at the beginning. It just didn’t jive with everything else he was trying to be.

The Down & Dirty:

I love The Underdogs Series by Kate Stewart. While The Guy on the Right was more of a layered romantic comedy, The Guy on the Left was more of an angsty romance. I loved Troy, Dante and Parker so much, but Clarissa, the heroine, is the one thing that held this back from being a 5 star read for me. The phenomenal, layered, angsty writing that Kate Stewart is known for was here for sure, and I can’t wait to read The Guy in the Middle for Lance’s story.

Rating: 4 Stars, 4 Heat

Purchase The Guy on the Left by Kate Stewart

See my review for The Guy on the Right
 

Related Posts:

  • The Other Half of the Grave Book Review
    The Other Half of the Grave by Jeaniene Frost | Book Review
  • august 2022 Recap
    August 2022 Recap
  • May 2022 Recap
    May 2022 Releases and Reviews Recap
  • Plus Size Player Danielle Allen
    Plus Size Player by Danielle Allen | ALC Review
  • Woman Down by Colleen Hoover
    Woman Down by Colleen Hoover | Audiobook Review
  • Christmas Romance Novels 2024
    Christmas Romance Novels 2024
«
»

4 stars, 4-5 Heat H's, 4-5 stars, Book Reviews, Books - 4+ Stars, Featured, Kate Stewart, Reviews 0

Follow Me Here!
Join our Facebook Group

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Stalk Me – I Like It

Stay in touch!

Subscribe to my monthly newsletter to stay up to date on my blog!

Welcome! Over 18 please

Ana's Attic

Ana’s Attic Book and Audiobook Blog was established in 2012.

Search the site

search by category

.
Disclosure: Ana's Attic is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com. Many of the books reviewed on Ana's Attic were provided by the publisher for free in exchange for an honest review. We never accept payment in any form for reviews or recommendations. For our full, in-depth Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policies, CLICK HERE. By using this website you are consenting to our Policies as set forth here.
DMCA.com Protection Status

Next Listen:

Listening:

Next Listen:

Next review:

Visit These pages:

Upcoming Book Releases
Formula 1 Romance Novels
Top Picks: Books and Audiobooks of 2025
Top books of 2024
Hannukah Romance Novels 2025
Christmas Romance Novels 2025
Tara Sivec Reading Guide
Books about books and authors
Bookish terms and abbreviations Booktok
Audiobook Tips & Tricks
Jewish Romance Novels
Taylor Jenkins Reid Book Connections

2025 Top Audiobooks Blog

2025 Top Audiobooks Blog

#officialfifty

#officialfifty

My son’s music

Affiliate:

Ana's Attic is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com.

Privacy Policy

For our full, in-depth Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policies, CLICK HERE. By using this website you are consenting to our Policies as set forth here.

The only time I collect e-mails is when you sign up for the newsletter or if you register This information is NEVER shared, and is only used to deliver your email to you.

Ana’s Attic does not share personal information with third parties nor do we store any information about your visit to this blog other than to analyze and optimize your content and reading experience through the use of cookies.

You can turn off the use of cookies at anytime by changing your specific browser settings.

We are not responsible for republished content from this blog on other blogs or websites without our permission.

This privacy policy is subject to change without notice and was last updated on May 24, 2018. If you have any questions feel free to contact me directly here: ana@anasattic.com

Please note:

This blog is meant for adults 18+ only. All opinions are my own and custom images are copyright protected. I never accept payment for reviews. All books reviewed are either purchased by me or provided by the publisher in exchange for an honest review. Prices reflected are valid at the time of post only. You are responsible for checking the correct price before completing the purchase.

For our full, in-depth Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policies, CLICK HERE. By using this website you are consenting to our Policies as set forth here.

Contest Winners: Contest Winners have 48 hours from my e-mail to get back to me or another winner is chosen. Flash Giveaway winners on Facebook are responsible for checking back to see if they are a winner. Mailed prizes are US only unless otherwise stated. I only pick rafflecopter winners once per month, all at once.

Instagram

anasatticblog

📖🎧Romance Book + Audiobook Reviews est. 2012
💻Honest Book Reviews
📚New Releases
💰Sale|Freebie Lists
🏁F1 Romances

This fun @meghanquinnbooks activity book is a Targ This fun @meghanquinnbooks activity book is a Target exclusive! How perfect is the title for Meghan? Would you get this? Looks fun!
🎄 FUN, FESTIVE, AND FILTHY! 🎧🔥 If National Lampoo 🎄 FUN, FESTIVE, AND FILTHY! 🎧🔥If National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation were a spicy romance, I imagine it would look a lot like Christmas Staycation by Meghan Quinn!I had SO MUCH FUN with this audiobook! 😂 The humor is completely juvenile, the family is chaotic, and Nolan has absolutely NO FILTER. Seriously, that man’s mind lives in the gutter, and I loved every minute of it.But underneath all the dirty jokes and Christmas chaos, there’s a surprisingly swoony romance. Nolan may be a walking sexual innuendo, but his sweet little gestures and golden retriever energy totally won me over. ❤️And the AUDIO! 🎧 The full-cast duet narration was fantastic. Shane East as the story’s narrator, especially when the characters start interacting with him, made the whole experience even funnier. Kelsey Navarro Foster and Brandon Francis were amazing as leads and made me wonder why I don’t see them used more. Swipe through for the tropes, some hilariously filthy quotes, my quick take, rating, and all the audiobook details!If you love outrageous humor, holiday romance, and a hero who has never met an inappropriate comment he didn’t want to make, add this one to your Christmas reading list!🎄 Full review with likes & dislikes at anasattic.comHave you read Meghan Quinn’s Kringletown Christmas books? Which is your favorite?
Over 200 romance book and romance audiobook releas Over 200 romance book and romance audiobook releases and 5 honest reviews in October. Check out my recap on the blog (link in bio)
You were all so much help on the glasses (I ended You were all so much help on the glasses (I ended up getting 2, I’m wearing one of them now), now I need help for my son’s wedding rehearsal dinner this Friday. Wedding is in Nashville. Which dress? Help!
Today is the LAST DAY to get so many good sales! C Today is the LAST DAY to get so many good sales! Check out my list, it’s the top post on my blog!Book sales • book deals • kindle deals • kindle books• romance books
🎄 What happens when a Christmas-loving PR girl tak 🎄 What happens when a Christmas-loving PR girl takes on the challenge of turning a grumpy, holiday-hating veterinarian into the town’s Mr. Holiday?A whole lot of Christmas fun, of course! ❤️Mistletoe All The Way by Lauren Blakely had me smiling through the holiday competition, the small-town shenanigans, and the growing connection between Eloise and Noah. Add in some adorable animals, a little mystery, and plenty of spice, and I was happily back in Evergreen Falls!🎧 Teddy Hamilton and Erin Mallon lead an amazing full-cast duet narration that makes this story even more fun. I seriously can’t imagine experiencing Lauren’s books any other way!If you love grumpy/sunshine Christmas romances, add this one to your holiday listening list!
I love how the narrator and Nolan break the fourth I love how the narrator and Nolan break the fourth wall in the Kringletown books.  Make sure the sound is on so you see what I mean. Christmas Staycation by @meghanquinnbooks had me laughing out loud! Nolan is a goofy immature perv with loyal, sweet and loving acts of service, and I am totally here for it. My full review is on the blog (link in bio). Meghan has been a long time favorite author, and she just keeps reinforcing that status! Grab this Christmas romcom on audio, the full cast narration audiobook makes it a full experience you don’t want to miss!Note: this is the Walmart special edition paperback.
Who else is excited for the Butcher and Blackbird Who else is excited for the Butcher and Blackbird movie?
3 new Formula 1 romance books in October! Until th 3 new Formula 1 romance books in October! Until the Lights Go Out by @authorelliana - Crash Course by @piperlawsonbooks - Overtake by @avenellis (releasing a month early!). I have well over 300 F1 romance books on my list. Check my link in bio or go to my blog, there is a banner for the list on top. Is anyone at the race in Austin this weekend? I’m so jealous! I’m watching practice 1 right now. Will you be watching this weekend? Any predictions?
I work for @sawyerbennett123 so I don’t formally r I work for @sawyerbennett123 so I don’t formally rate her books, but I wanted to share some thoughts on Locke, the second in the Portland Wildfire hockey romance series. If you like Hockey romance, get on this series! I’m really enjoying starting with a brand new, just-forming team from the start. I have more thoughts on my blog (link in bio) .
Go see YOU CAN SEE EVERYTHING in the theater ASAP. Go see YOU CAN SEE EVERYTHING in the theater ASAP. This movie was fascinating. It’s long and you won’t want to get up so make sure you pee, pick a comfy theater, and don’t drink your whole bucket of soda. I didn’t think I wanted to see a documentary in the theater, I was wrong. Sold out theater and nobody got up during the whole 3 hour film. Everyone in the bathroom was saying how great it was and how much they had to go the whole time lol. It still has a 98% RT score.
Mistletoe All The Way by Lauren Blakely took me ri Mistletoe All The Way by Lauren Blakely took me right back to the charming Christmas town of Evergreen Falls, and I loved being there again! 🎄❤️A grumpy, Christmas-hating veterinarian, a sunshine heroine who lives for the holidays, a fun Christmas competition, adorable animals, and a little mystery made this such an entertaining listen!And the full-cast duet narration led by Teddy Hamilton and Erin Mallon? SO GOOD! Lauren Blakely’s books are made for audio, and this one is no exception.This is book 3 in the Evergreen Falls series, but it can absolutely be enjoyed as a standalone. Perfect for getting into the holiday spirit! See my full review on the blog at anasattic dot com (link in bio)
I am SO EXCITED to see In A Holidaze by @christina I am SO EXCITED to see In A Holidaze by @christinalauren brought to life, especially with Rob Lowe (my lifetime crush 🤤). It releases on @netflix December 2. You can see the full trailer on either of the tagged accounts on Instagram and I will post the link on Facebook. I am loving all the book to movie adaptations so much, I can’t keep up! Who else is excited for this one?
A Very Good Bad Idea by Emma Chase is now availabl A Very Good Bad Idea by Emma Chase is now available on Kindle! 📚This fun, over-the-top enemies-to-lovers romcom has hilarious banter, outrageous pranks, and two rivals forced to live together for four months with no phones, internet, or outside contact! I especially loved watching the romance develop once Jade and Damon finally let their guards down.I listened to the audiobook with fantastic duet narration by Sean Masters and Brooke Bloomingdale, but now you can grab it for your Kindle, too.My full review is on the blog (link in bio)
I put this on Facebook and the votes were pretty e I put this on Facebook and the votes were pretty even for each pair. Tell me your choice! (Note: there are 2 Gucci so let me know which one if you choose Gucci). I would love a man’s choice, but I’m only friends with women on here!Please help me choose!
Follow on Instagram

Copyright

All images and text on this blog are credited to Ana’s Attic, unless otherwise stated. Book covers are from Amazon.com. Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material (including translations) without express and written permission from Ana’s Attic’s author is strictly prohibited.

Excerpts (no longer than a short paragraph) and links to this blog are permitted, providing that full credit is given to Ana’s Attic with clear and specific direction to the original content.

For our full, in-depth Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policies, CLICK HERE. By using this website you are consenting to our Policies as set forth here.

Facebook Page

Wicked Book Weekend

Ana's Attic Book Blog © 2026

Web Design and Development by emr design studio