• Reviews
    • 5+++++++ Stars
    • 5 stars
    • 4-5 stars
      • 4 stars
      • 4.25 Stars
      • 4.5 stars
      • 4.75 Stars
    • 3-4 stars
    • audiobook
      • Audiobooks Under 3 stars
      • Audiobook 3 stars
      • Audiobook 3.5 stars
      • Audiobook 3.75 Stars
      • Audiobook 4 stars
      • Audiobook 4.25 Stars
      • Audiobook 4.5 Stars
      • Audiobook 4.75 Stars
      • Audiobook 5 stars
      • Audiobook 5+++ Stars
  • Series Orders
    • The Complete Guide To Kristen Ashley
  • What to Read after Fifty
  • About~Privacy
    • Advertising
    • Contact ~ Review Requests
    • Terms and Conditions. Privacy Policy.
    • Archive
  • Wicked Book Weekend

Ana's Attic Book Blog

Romance Book and Audiobook Reviews and Deals

  • Ana's Attic Book Blog
  • Home
  • Reviews
    • 5+++++++ Stars
    • 5 stars
    • 4-5 stars
      • 4 stars
      • 4.25 Stars
      • 4.5 stars
      • 4.75 Stars
    • 3-4 stars
    • Audiobooks
      • Audiobook 5+++ Stars
      • Audiobook 5 stars
      • Audiobook 4.75 Stars
      • Audiobook 4.5 Stars
      • Audiobook 4.25 Stars
      • Audiobook 4 stars
      • Audiobook 3.75 Stars
      • Audiobook 3.5 stars
      • Audiobook 3 stars
      • Audiobooks Under 3 stars
  • New-Sale-Free-Preorder
    • Monthly Release Recaps
  • Favorite Lists
    • 2021 Top Picks
    • 2020 Top Picks
    • 2019 Top Picks
    • 2018 Top Picks
    • 2017 Top Picks
    • 2016 Top Picks
    • 2015 Top Picks
    • 2014 Top Picks
    • 2013 Top Picks
    • 2012 Top Picks
    • Top Picks and Favorite Lists
    • Recaps and Best Sellers
  • Book Extras
  • Upcoming Book Releases

Audiobook Review – Fall From India Place by Samantha Young

11/08/2014

Fall from India Place

Fall From India Place by Samantha Young

Audiobook Review. Part of an interrelated standalone series.
Adult Contemporary (though this one felt more NA)

I am a HUGE fan of the On Dublin Street series by Samantha Young. I fell behind on my reading and never got around to reading the copy of Fall From India Place on my Kindle. So when I was looking for an audiobook, I grabbed it, forgetting to listen to the sample. I just didn’t expect the narrator to be a young lady with a Scottish accent! Once I got over that (which was actually really cool), I found her to be a bit too slow in her pace, and tried to speed it up, but it didn’t quite work. Some may love the slightly slower pace, and I got used to it, but to me it made a slightly slow book even slower.

In this case it is difficult for me to separate the audiobook from the story. The narrator was just so sad all of the time. And yes, Hannah (the character) was too, but it was kind of sad and depressing to listen to, despite my enjoying the accent.

Hannah is Ellie’s little sister. A character who was nerdy and happy in previous books if I remember correctly. Fall From India Place skips 5 years into the future from the last ODS book, and a lot has changed. Hannah fell in love, lost her virginity, and had her heart broken by Marco D’Allesandro 5 years earlier. She is now a teacher, and after finding an old photo of Marco 5 years after she last saw him, she can’t stop thinking of him. Sadly pining for him….his departure from Scotland 5 years earlier was something she had yet to get over.

QUOTE MARKI’d felt lost for a long time after he left. It had taken a while to find my strength and independence again. It had meant hardening my heart and creating little locked doors in my soul so that only the people I trusted implicitly could ever make it inside to touch it.”

There was a very slow ramp-up to the meat of the story. A lot was shown in flashback, and Samantha took her time unveiling the whole situation. But without giving too much away, Marco comes back. And when he sees Hannah again, he wants her back.

 

Fall from India Place

But it isn’t so easy for Hannah. His leaving truly broke her.

QUOTE MARKShould it be this hard, though, Marco?”…..Should it hurt this much?”
“I don’t know. I don’t know what the rules are.”

He works so hard to convince her…

QUOTE MARKI’m your best friend. You’ve just forgotten. My fault, I know. I can help you remember.”

But some things just couldn’t be forgotten, and Hannah was not just going to give in.

QUOTE MARKWhy did you really ask me to meet you tonight, Marco?”

“Because, when I’m with you it feels like everything’s going to be okay. I can’t explain it.”

I enjoyed the story, will definitely continue with the series, but this was the weakest so far for me.

Likes:

  • Visiting with all of the previous ODS characters.
  • Seeing Cole as a grown-up, and I loved his and Hannah’s friendship.
  • The kids!!!! (I don’t want to spoil one of the best lines.)
  • I liked the teaching moments, and how Hannah helped the adults in her literacy class.
  • Having a young narrator with a Scottish accent was a great touch.

Dislikes:

  • It was a very slow moving, slow building, slow revealing story compared to others in the series.
  • Hannah just pissed me off. I did not like the way she handled things and blamed Marco for things beyond his control.

Audiobook comments:

Chloe Lynn had a great Scottish accent and did the male voice very well.  I wanted to speed it up because she was a bit too slow, but my app sped it up a bit too much, so I stuck it out with the slow. She was very sad and soft spoken, which, although Hannah is sad, was way too sad sounding to me. I loved the idea of a young Scottish narrator, but I would have liked her to speak a little peppier.

Rating: Story: 4 stars, Audio: 3.5 stars, Heat 3.5 

Story:

stars_4

Audio:

stars_3half

Heat:

Flame_THREEhalf copy

I never look at other reviews before I post mine. But in this case I took a peek. I wanted to make sure I wasn’t basing my opinions just on the narrator and that I was able to separate it enough to have a true opinion of the story. Many of the reviews I saw said the same thing, that the book was a little slower paced, that we lost the happy Hannah, and that she was a little too stubborn. I enjoyed Fall from India Place, but it just wasn’t my favorite of the series.

PrintPurchase Fall from India Place

Amazon | Audible | BN.com 

 

Print Click covers to go to Amazon. Most can stand alone.

See the full reading order with links to my reviews plus links to a ton of male POV Bonus scenes here.

.
review_fall-from-india_SQUARE

Related posts:

  • November 2023 Release and Review RecapNovember 2023 Release and Review Recap
  • Contemporary Jewish Romance BooksJewish Contemporary Romance Novels
  • Contemporary Hanukkah Romance NovelsHanukkah Romance Novels 2023
  • The Covenant Series by Jennifer L. ArmentroutThe Covenant Series by Jennifer L. Armentrout | Audiobook Series Review
  • Moms Who Read Romance Novels by Jenifer Goldin | Book ReviewMoms Who Read Romance Novels by Jenifer Goldin | Book Review
«
»

3-4 stars, 4 stars, All About Books, audiobook, Audiobook 4 stars, Reviews, Samantha Young 2

Follow Me Here!

Join our Facebook Group

Comments

  1. Loraine Oliver says

    11/08/2014 at 1:51 pm

    I love listening to audio books when I am cleaning the house, or in my case I have to go to the doctor quite often due to my health, so I like to listen to them in the cab on my way over or back from appts, while waiting at my appts. so I listen quite often!I like to also read the books while listening that is cool too! Great review, love all of Samantha Young’s books too!

    Reply
    • Ana's Attic says

      11/10/2014 at 11:17 pm

      Thanks!

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Stalk Me – I Like It

Stay in touch!

Subscribe to my monthly newsletter to stay up to date on my blog!

Welcome! Over 18 please

Ana's Attic

Ana’s Attic Book and Audiobook Blog was established in 2012.

Search this site:

search by category

.
Disclosure: Ana's Attic is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com. Many of the books reviewed on Ana's Attic were provided by the publisher for free in exchange for an honest review. We never accept payment in any form for reviews or recommendations. For our full, in-depth Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policies, CLICK HERE. By using this website you are consenting to our Policies as set forth here.
DMCA.com Protection Status

reading:

Listening:

reading:

next review:

Visit These pages:

Visit These pages:

Founding Member

Passionflix

#officialfifty

#officialfifty

New single out now!

Affiliate:

Ana's Attic is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com.

Privacy Policy

For our full, in-depth Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policies, CLICK HERE. By using this website you are consenting to our Policies as set forth here.

The only time I collect e-mails is when you sign up for the newsletter or if you register This information is NEVER shared, and is only used to deliver your email to you.

Ana’s Attic does not share personal information with third parties nor do we store any information about your visit to this blog other than to analyze and optimize your content and reading experience through the use of cookies.

You can turn off the use of cookies at anytime by changing your specific browser settings.

We are not responsible for republished content from this blog on other blogs or websites without our permission.

This privacy policy is subject to change without notice and was last updated on May 24, 2018. If you have any questions feel free to contact me directly here: ana@anasattic.com

Please note:

This blog is meant for adults 18+ only. All opinions are my own and custom images are copyright protected. I never accept payment for reviews. All books reviewed are either purchased by me or provided by the publisher in exchange for an honest review. Prices reflected are valid at the time of post only. You are responsible for checking the correct price before completing the purchase.

For our full, in-depth Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policies, CLICK HERE. By using this website you are consenting to our Policies as set forth here.

Contest Winners: Contest Winners have 48 hours from my e-mail to get back to me or another winner is chosen. Flash Giveaway winners on Facebook are responsible for checking back to see if they are a winner. Mailed prizes are US only unless otherwise stated. I only pick rafflecopter winners once per month, all at once.

Instagram

anasatticblog

📖Romance Book &
🎧Audiobook Reviews since 2012
📚New Releases
💰Sale|Freebie Lists
📆 @startingon_monday
🏖Wicked Book Weekend

Ana's Attic Book Blog
I haven’t been able to get What You Do To Me by I haven’t been able to get What You Do To Me by @rochellebweinstein out of my head. Told in 3 timelines, now, the 90’s and the 70’s, it’s about a Rolling Stone reporter’s search for the muse of a hugely popular song. This completely unique story is really sticking with me and it’s one of the ones I’ve been recommending a lot lately. 

📚Read it: https://amzn.to/3RaQVW3
🎧Listen: https://amzn.to/3SQ7F5Y
💻My review: https://anasattic.com/what-you-do-to-me/
Both the book and Audiobook are FREE in Kindle Unlimited.

#audiobookreview #bookreview #bookstagram #audiobookstagram #Rollingstone #romancereads #recommendedreading #kindleunlimited #kindleunlimitedaudio #jewishlit #jewishromance #historicalromance #1970s #1990s
Part 2 of my November mini review recap. I think o Part 2 of my November mini review recap. I think only my mom watches these, but I’m doing it anyway 🤗. You can find the full list of all the November book and audiobook releases as well as links to all my reviews on the recap post on my blog. 
-
#bookstagram #audiobookstagram #bookreviews #bookreviewsofinstagram #honestbookreviews #audiobooksofinstagram #audiobookreview #jewishreads #womensfiction #romancereader #romancebookstagram
My recap of all of my November blog posts as well My recap of all of my November blog posts as well as the hundreds of book and audiobook releases from November is live on the blog. 
https://anasattic.com/november-2023-release-and-review-recap/
—
#bookstagram #audiobookstagram #monthlywrapup #novemberrecap #bookreviews #audiobookreviews #fantasyromance #jenniferlarmentrout #fourthwing #ironflame #catherinecowles #jewishromance #hanukkahromance #jewishbookstagrammer #jewishbookstagram #bookblogger #audiobooks
Part one of my November mini review recap. You can Part one of my November mini review recap. You can see all of the November book and audiobook releases and links to all of my reviews at anasattic.com
—
#bookstagram #novemberrecap #novemberbooks #bookreview #audiobookreview #booksbooksbooks #fourthwing #ironflame #jewishbooks #holidaybooks #fantasybooks #romanticsuspense #romancereads #audible #audiobookstagram
I’ve updated my Hanukkah Romance Book List for 2 I’ve updated my Hanukkah Romance Book List for 2023! Have you read any of these? I love holiday books! 
I’ve also posted a new huge list of Jewish Romances, and I will have my Christmas book list up this week and my list of Formula 1 romances is coming soon too. 

—> https://anasattic.com/hanukkah-romance-novels-2023/

#bookstagram #romancebooks #holidayromancebooks #hanukkahromance #jewishromance #jewishbookstagramtour #jewishbookstagram #hanukkahbooks #jewishreads #jewishbooks
I have a new list of Hanukkah Romances and another I have a new list of Hanukkah Romances and another for Jewish Contemporary Romance on my blog Anasattic.com Let me know if I missed any good ones! 
—
#hanukkahbooks #jewishreads #holidaybooks #holidayromancebooks #spicyhanukkahbooks #chanukah #jewishbookstagramtour #jewishbookstagram #jewishromance #bookstagram #holidaybookstagram
I liked Maybe Once Maybe Twice. I liked the music, I liked Maybe Once Maybe Twice. I liked the music, the stories, and the characters for the most part, and I loved the camp stuff. But the pacing was off for me and there were a lot of timeline changes that I lost track of a few times. I think this one may have been better reading over audio. This book contains triggers, read the warnings!
⭐️⭐️⭐️
—

📖Read it: https://amzn.to/3RjGtLZ
🎧Listen: https://amzn.to/47uVUGL
💻My review: https://anasattic.com/maybe-once-maybe-twice/
—
#bookstagram #audiobook #audiobookstagram #audiblebooks #hoopla #hoopladigital #audiobookreview #bookreview #romancebooks #romancereader #honestbookreview #jewishbookstagrammer #jewishromancebooks #romancebooks
I’m spending 30 minutes reading and enjoying a g I’m spending 30 minutes reading and enjoying a gorgeous Florida morning before I start cooking for tomorrow. I’m in charge of stuffing, sweet potato casserole and carrot soufflé. One of my boys is home for Thanksgiving, the other is playing a show in Louisville and Cleveland this weekend, but at least he will be home for Christmas week!  How do you spend the day before Thanksgiving? I’m so glad I’m not traveling. 
—
#bookstagram #bookstagrammer #amreading #amreadingromance #booklover #kindle #bookish #floridalife
I know everyone in the world has posted reviews, b I know everyone in the world has posted reviews, but I just realized I never shared mine here. You can see my more detailed review on the blog. 

Iron Flame felt like a 5-star read when I finished. But if I compare it to Fourth Wing or just sit down and look at my notes I realize that I had a lot of negative notes when I had none in the first book. It suffered from a bit of a sophmore slump, especially in the beginning, then too much happened that didn’t all really advance the story. It was like each chapter or two had a new challenge to deal with —like it’s written for episodic TV (which will be happening on Amazon). I still absolutely loved it but I will definitely need to reread this before the next one because I feel like I missed some stuff and some stuff didn’t make 100% sense to me. There were a lot of new characters who I don’t care about adding to my confusion. I loved Iron Flame, but not as much as Fourth Wing which was a much simpler book about a military college—Iron Flame was about the war. Still, I absolutely can’t wait to see what she does with book 3!

IRON FLAME:
📚Read it: https://amzn.to/3GbxEgQ
🎧Listen: https://amzn.to/3GaqkC1
💻My review: https://anasattic.com/iron-flame-rebecca-yarros/

FOURTH WING:
📚Read it: https://amzn.to/3SXV9lf
🎧Listen: https://amzn.to/3SOTzSn
💻My review: https://anasattic.com/fourth-wing-rebecca-yarros/

#bookstagram #bookish #audiobookstagram #ironflame #fourthwing #dragons #commissionsearned #fantasyromance #rebeccayarros #audiobookreview #bookreview #romantasy #bookseries #booktok #trendybooks #hypedbooks #recommendedreading
What You Do To Me by @rochellebweinstein is a comp What You Do To Me by @rochellebweinstein is a complex and completely unique story that had me riveted the entire time. I especially loved the story of the young Argentinian singer and the sheltered Jewish girl in the 1970’s and the sluething of the Rolling Stone reporter to find the muse to the famous song. If you enjoy music-based romances, this one will be right up your alley.

📚Read it: https://amzn.to/3RaQVW3
🎧Listen: https://amzn.to/3SQ7F5Y
💻My review: https://anasattic.com/what-you-do-to-me/
Both the book and Audiobook are FREE in Kindle Unlimited.

#audiobookreview #bookreview #bookstagram #audiobookstagram #Rollingstone #romancereads #recommendedreading #kindleunlimited #kindleunlimitedaudio #jewishlit #jewishromance #historicalromance #1970s #1990s #rochellebweinstein
Roan, Aspen and Cady may be my favorites of the Lo Roan, Aspen and Cady may be my favorites of the Lost and Found series. I love kids in romance novels and this romance was everything I love. The only thing that held me back from 5 stars was that I guessed the bad guy. After reading so many of her amazing books, they are starting to be a bit similar, but that could be the case with all small-town romantic suspense books. Catherine is one of my very top favorites and I can’t wait for the next in the series. I’m hoping I’m surprised this time! PS: the narration by Maxine Mitchell and Zachary Webber made it even better. 

📖Read it: https://amzn.to/3MsHGxx
🎧Listen: https://amzn.to/3seKZS8
💻My review: https://anasattic.com/shadows-of-you-catherine-cowles/
📚The Series: https://amzn.to/3QGpMKp

#bookstagram #catherinecowles #favoriteauthor #romanticsuspensebook #contemporaryromance #kindle #Audible #audiblebooks #bookcovers #bookcoverlove #specialedition #recommendedreading #bookseries #amazonaffiliate
How do you do most of your reading? Physical books How do you do most of your reading? Physical books? Tablet? E-reader? Phone? Audiobook? Or do you read another way? 
—
—
#bookstagram #booklover #bookish #ebooks #audiobooks #audiobookstagram #kindle #books #booksbooksbooks #readersofinstagram #booklover #bookblogger #bookstagrammer
If you loved Kristen Ashley’s Ghosts & Reincarna If you loved Kristen Ashley’s Ghosts & Reincarnation series, you will love Too Good To Be True. It wasn’t my favorite because I’m just not into the old historical estates in England and so much was about the house itself. Part historical and part present-time, I liked the couple, but this just wasn’t really for me compared to all the other KA books I’ve loved. 

📖Read it: https://amzn.to/46fL99S
🎧Listen: https://amzn.to/3MOpG0F
💻My review: https://anasattic.com/too-good-to-be-true/
See my Complete Guide to Kristen Ashley: https://anasattic.com/the-complete-guide-to-kristen-ashley/

—
#bookreview #honestbookreviews #favoriteauthor #romanticsuspense #lristenashley #booklover #romancereader #bookstagram
How do you organize your bookshelves? By color? Al How do you organize your bookshelves? By color? Alphabetically? By genre? Do you read the books on your shelf?

Mine are done by author and genre. My favorite authors or ones that I have more than 6 books from have their own shelf or shelf space. The rest are done by genre. 95% of my books are signed, and I do not read them! I read the ebook or audiobook. 

What about you?
—
#bookstagram #bookshelves #bookshelf #bookshelvesofinstagram #bookish #signedbooks #booklover #homelibrary #homeoffice #bookshelfdecor #shelfie #romancebooks #romancebookstagrammer
Did you know you can get the entire series of The Did you know you can get the entire series of The Runaways by @devneyperry for only one credit? 5 amazing books, 5 separate romances, but they all connect beautifully. It was a great binge! 
—
📚The Series bundle: https://amzn.to/3RtkEdj
🎧Series bundle on Audible: https://amzn.to/3rhD861
—
#devneyperry #audiobookreview #audible #kindleunlimited #bookseries #seriesbundle #affiliate #bookreview #bookstagram #audiobookstagram #romancebooks #recommendedreading
Load More... Follow on Instagram

Copyright

All images and text on this blog are credited to Ana’s Attic, unless otherwise stated. Book covers are from Amazon.com. Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material (including translations) without express and written permission from Ana’s Attic’s author is strictly prohibited.

Excerpts (no longer than a short paragraph) and links to this blog are permitted, providing that full credit is given to Ana’s Attic with clear and specific direction to the original content.

For our full, in-depth Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policies, CLICK HERE. By using this website you are consenting to our Policies as set forth here.

Facebook Page

Wicked Book Weekend

Ana's Attic Book Blog © 2023

Web Design and Development by emr design studio